23 August 2022>: Meta-Analysis
Optimal Surgical Treatment Method for Anterior Cruciate Ligament Rupture: Results from a Network Meta-Analysis
Yudi Wu 1CDEF , Yajia Li 2BCD , Jia Guo 2BC , Qiangxiang Li 34BC , Jianhuang Wu 35BCD , Ziqin Cao 5ABCDEF* , Yulin Song 6ABCDEF*DOI: 10.12659/MSM.937118
Med Sci Monit 2022; 28:e937118
Table 1 Baseline characteristics of included studies.
Author | No. | Year | Number of patients | Mean age | Male/Female | Traumatic mechanism | Surgery method | Mean follow-up (months) | Study design | Control intervention I | Control intervention II | Control intervention III |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Gagliardi AG et al []31 | 1 | 2019 | 179 | 15.48 | 87/92 | Low-energy trauma 164High-energy trauma 0 | Arthroscopy | 36.0 | Cohort study | Autograft | Repair with augmentation | / |
Meunier A et al []39 | 2 | 2007 | 100 | 21.44 | 68/32 | NR | Arthroscopy | 180.0 | Randomized clinical trial | Repair with augmentation | Repair without augmentation | Autograft |
Hoogeslag RAG et al []19 | 3 | 2019 | 48 | 21.50 | 13820 | NR | Arthroscopy | 24.0 | Randomized clinical trial | Repair with augmentation | Autograft | / |
Achtnich A et al []27 | 4 | 2016 | 40 | 31.80 | NR | NR | Arthroscopy | 28.0 | Non-randomized clinical trial | Repair without augmentation | Autograft | / |
Bottoni CR et al []29 | 5 | 2015 | 97 | 29.05 | 84/13 | Low-energy trauma 98High-energy trauma 2 | Arthroscopy | 120.0 | Randomized clinical trial | Autograft | Non-irradiated allograft | / |
Sporsheim AN et al []44 | 6 | 2019 | 150 | 29.00 | 36/28 | NR | Arthroscopy | 360.0 | Randomized clinical trial | Repair without augmentation | Repair with augmentation | Autograft |
Sun K et al []46 | 7 | 2009 | 99 | 30.55 | 70/29 | Low-energy trauma 88High-energy trauma 10 | Arthroscopy | 31.0 | Randomized clinical trial | Autograft | Non-irradiated allograft | Irradiated allograft |
Murray MM et al []41 | 8 | 2020 | 100 | 17.00 | 44/56 | NR | Arthroscopy | 24.0 | Randomized clinical trial | Repair without augmentation | Autograft | / |
Schliemann B et al []43 | 9 | 2017 | 60 | 28.65 | 23/37 | NR | Arthroscopy | 12.0 | Randomized clinical trial | Repair with augmentation | Autograft | / |
Wang HD et al []52 | 10 | 2017 | 57 | 32.70 | 19/38 | NR | Arthroscopy | 36.0 | Cohort study | Hybrid | Autograft | / |
Murray MM et al []40 | 11 | 2016 | 20 | 24.35 | 6/14 | Low-energy trauma 19High-energy trauma 1 | Arthroscopy | 3.0 | Cohort study | Repair without augmentation | Autograft | / |
Edgar CM et al []30 | 12 | 2008 | 83 | 29.22 | 46/37 | NR | Arthroscopy | 50.0 | Cohort study | Autograft | Non-irradiated allograft | / |
Li J et al []37 | 13 | 2016 | 80 | 31.37 | 50/30 | NR | Arthroscopy | 67.2 | Randomized clinical trial | Autograft | Irradiated allograft | Hybrid |
Kösters C et al []34 | 14 | 2020 | 85 | 28.16 | 56/29 | NR | Arthroscopy | 24.0 | Randomized clinical trial | Repair with augmentation | Autograft | / |
Sun K et al []60 | 15 | 2009 | 156 | 32.26 | 124/32 | Low-energy trauma 154High-energy trauma 2 | Arthroscopy | 67.2 | Randomized clinical trial | Autograft | Non-irradiated allograft | / |
Sun K et al []47 | 16 | 2009 | 65 | 24.89 | 17/48 | Low-energy trauma 61High-energy trauma 4 | Arthroscopy | 31.0 | Randomized clinical trial | Autograft | Irradiated allograft | / |
Sun K et al []48 | 17 | 2011 | 67 | 30.60 | 15/52 | Low-energy trauma 61High-energy trauma 4 | Arthroscopy | 42.2 | Randomized clinical trial | Autograft | Irradiated allograft | / |
Sun K et al []58 | 18 | 2011 | 186 | 30.42 | 149/37 | Low-energy trauma 61High-energy trauma 8 | Arthroscopy | 93.0 | Randomized clinical trial | Autograft | Non-irradiated allograft | / |
Jia YH et al []33 | 19 | 2015 | 106 | 29.50 | 54/52 | NR | Arthroscopy | 81.0 | Randomized clinical trial | Non-irradiated allograft | Autograft | / |
Tian S et al []50 | 20 | 2016 | 121 | 30.21 | 96/25 | Low-energy trauma 113High-energy trauma 8 | Arthroscopy | 55.2 | Randomized clinical trial | Autograft | Non-irradiated allograft | / |
Tian S et al []49 | 21 | 2016 | 83 | 28.89 | 66/17 | Low-energy trauma 77High-energy trauma 6 | Arthroscopy | 82.8 | Randomized clinical trial | Autograft | Irradiated allograft | / |
Yoo SH et al []54 | 22 | 2015 | 132 | 27.09 | 120/12 | NR | Arthroscopy | 33.6 | Randomized clinical trial | Autograft | Non-irradiated allograft | / |
Tian S et al []51 | 23 | 2010 | 69 | 31.25 | 56/13 | Low-energy trauma 60High-energy trauma 9 | Arthroscopy | 38.5 | Randomized clinical trial | Autograft | Irradiated allograft | / |
Bi HY et al []28 | 24 | 2013 | 86 | 32.00 | 60/26 | NR | Arthroscopy | 38.5 | Randomized clinical trial | Autograft | Non-irradiated allograft | / |
Sun K et al []45 | 25 | 2004 | 53 | 32.34 | 44/9 | NR | Arthroscopy | 19.0 | Randomized clinical trial | Autograft | Non-irradiated allograft | / |
Gorschewsky O et al []32 | 26 | 2002 | 201 | 32.97 | 150/51 | NR | Arthroscopy | 24.0 | Randomized clinical trial | Autograft | Non-irradiated allograft | / |
Li J et al []38 | 27 | 2015 | 95 | 30.62 | 50/45 | Low-energy trauma 87High-energy trauma 8 | Arthroscopy | 71.2 | Randomized clinical trial | Autograft | Irradiated allograft | Hybrid |
Murray MM et al []18 | 28 | 2019 | 20 | 24.35 | 6/14 | Low-energy trauma 19High-energy trauma 1 | Arthroscopy | 24.0 | Cohort study | Repair without augmentation | Autograft | / |
Darnley JE et al []56 | 29 | 2016 | 54 | 20.90 | 34/20 | NR | Arthroscopy | 24.0 | Cohort study | Autograft | Hybrid | / |
Zheng X et al []55 | 30 | 2019 | 97 | 30.77 | 69/28 | NR | Arthroscopy | 20.1 | Randomized clinical trial | Autograft | Hybrid | Irradiated allograft |
Kraeutler MJ et al []35 | 31 | 2017 | 148 | 33.78 | NR | NR | Arthroscopy | 50.1 | Randomized clinical trial | Autograft | Hybrid | / |
Pennock AT et al []42 | 32 | 2016 | 40 | 15.65 | 15/25 | NR | Arthroscopy | 24.0 | Non-randomized clinical trial | Hybrid | Autograft | / |
Leo BM et al []36 | 33 | 2016 | 95 | 27.20 | 60/35 | NR | Arthroscopy | 24.0 | Non-randomized clinical trial | Autograft | Hybrid | / |
Xu H et al []59 | 34 | 2018 | 76 | 35.66 | 52/24 | Low-energy trauma 67High-energy trauma 9 | Arthroscopy | 27.0 | Cohort study | Autograft | Hybrid | / |
Burrus MT et al []57 | 35 | 2015 | 58 | 26.90 | 20/38 | NR | Arthroscopy | 46.2 | Non-randomized clinical trial | Hybrid | Autograft | / |
Xu H et al []53 | 36 | 2017 | 68 | 33.90 | 43/25 | NR | Arthroscopy | 24.0 | Non-randomized clinical trial | Autograft | Hybrid | / |